@WintiBear Most of my picks for the jobs are based on personal experience, which is why Cleric and Elf aren't where you'd put them as I haven't seen their full potential (or any at all)
I separated the versions of the Dark Lord into different tiers because each one feels different to me and has a different impact on the story
The Dark Lord appears the most and has a better design than the Darker Lord, the Darker Lord is super ugly, appears very little and the personality feels a little more vague compared to the Dark Lord, and when I put ahem ahem in the "doesn't appear too much in the story" I was talking about the actual curse and the reborn form, not the curse as a Dark Lord
I highly disagree with you on Popstar! Not only can they end quarrels quickly, but they're able to make stronger Miis go a second time, put all Miis at a high relationship, use Earworm which is a super broken move, and they can literally revive Miis at a high level!
But like, in my experience with using Pop Star they spam Love Song everytime they get the chance, and when they use Angelic Voice the chance is extremely low and the skill easily gets overlooked by the Cleric’s 100% guaranteed “Giga Resurrection”